The Hidden Cost of Playing Small in Your Coaching Business

Show Notes

As coaches, we love to help, which is great. However, we do not like to put ourselves out there, so we often play small. We do not want to be visible. We do not want to be the one beating our drum and telling the world how great we are.

And if people cannot find us, we cannot help them. That is one of the downsides of playing small, we lose opportunities, we lose potential clients, and we lose the chance to collaborate with people who could put us in front of their audience. It is much easier when someone else stands up and says, “Hey, you are fantastic!” rather than having to say it yourself. However, nobody is going to do that if they do not know you exist.

Playing small is probably costing you your coaching business but there are many different ways to overcome this.

Be Visible

You have to recognise when you are stunting your own growth and not allowing yourself to become the incredible coach you are meant to be. If people do not know about you, they might never get the help they need.

Sometimes, stepping out and asking for help takes a lot of bravery on their part. If they almost reach out but do not quite see you or connect with you in the right way, they might miss their one opportunity to change their life. And here is the hard truth: when potential clients approach you and the consultation does not go well, they often never try again.

That is not meant to put pressure on you, but it is the reality. You need to make sure you are visible, showing up, and letting people know you are available.

Perfectionism Holds You Back

One of the main reasons we play small is perfectionism.

We worry about not knowing enough, not having all the answers, or not being “ready” to put ourselves out there. But here is the amazing thing about coaching: you do not have to know it all. That is not your job.

Your job is to guide your clients, not to have all the answers for them. They already know the answers – they just do not know they know them. That is where your coaching skills come in. Through open-ended questions, powerful reflections, and curiosity, you help your clients unlock their own potential.

You do not have to be perfect from day one. Nobody is. Every great coach started where you are right now.

Remember the 10,000-hour rule? Mastery takes time. But it all begins with one hour, ten hours, one hundred hours. You cannot get to 10,000 hours if you do not start.

Be Confident

Another reason we play small is the lack of confidence.

And here is the tricky thing about confidence: the less you do, the less confident you become. The more you put yourself out there, the more confident you will feel.

A lot of coaches who say, “I was so good in training, but now I do not have the confidence.” The truth is, confidence comes from doing the work.

You might need to offer some free or low-cost sessions at first but only as a temporary measure. If you stay in that space for too long, it becomes a cycle that keeps you stuck.

A great rule of thumb is this: every five clients, raise your rates slightly.

Even if it is just a small increase, it helps shift your mindset and ensures you are not undervaluing yourself. Eventually, as you build experience and confidence, you can charge what you are truly worth.

The Fear of Rejection

Fear of rejection is another reason we hold back. “What if they say no?” Well… what if they do? Will you die? Probably not but you will learn from the experience. Maybe the consultation took too long. Maybe you asked a question that could have been framed differently. Maybe you did not ask a question that would have helped the client see the value in working with you. Instead of fearing rejection, use it as a learning opportunity.

If someone says, “I do not have the money, try asking: “If money was not an issue, would you go ahead?”, “Is there anything else stopping you?”

Often, the problem is not the money. It is that you have not demonstrated the value of your coaching.

If fear of rejection is holding you back, go back and listen to Episode 270: Overcoming the Fear of Rejection.

Go Out There

How do you know if you are playing small?

You are not showing up consistently on social media.
You are not putting yourself forward for speaking opportunities.
You avoid networking or struggle to confidently explain what you do.
You are undercharging and afraid to raise your prices.

Years ago, competition was limited to a few local businesses. Now, your competition is global. That is a great thing because it means you can work with clients anywhere in the world but it also means you must be visible.

Mindset Is Everything

At the end of the day, the biggest battle is the one happening in your mind. If you do not believe in yourself, your potential clients will not either. It is time to reframe your thinking

Start telling yourself: “I am a great coach”, “I have valuable skills”, “I am capable of building a thriving business.”

You do not need another certification. You do not need to be perfect. You just need to start.

Get Support and Borrow Belief

Sometimes, we need to borrow belief from others before we fully believe in ourselves. Get a mentor or coach who will push you forward. Surround yourself with people who see your potential. Say yes to opportunities, even when they feel uncomfortable.

If you are still hesitating, start small. Post one story on social media. Introduce yourself as a coach at your next event. Raise your rates slightly with your next client.

Just start. Because if you keep hiding, nobody will find you.

Contacts

Linkedin
Facebook
Cathy Smith Coaching